Break the Crash Diet Cycle

In 2013 I was asked to be a health and fitness columnist for the website Edge On The Net.  What a compliment!  I have been so proud and flattered to be a part of an internet magazine in which I have faith and from which I get great enjoyment.  I’d like to feature the columns I have written, here, with the link to the final edit (my editor, Bobby McGuire, is a great editor who changes very few things and when he does, it is always the right change – by comparing the stories side by side, one can see how great an editor he is).   Most of my stories are ones he assigns me.   Like this one on Crash Dieting.


 Halloween is in a few days.  My husband and I are doing what we always do for Halloween – we are going to a big dance party to celebrate a friend’s birthday.  So I’m on a strict diet and doing two-a-days at the gym.  After all, at a gay Halloween dance party, your body is your costume, right?  That’s my current goal: to look my best on Halloween.  After that, the finish line I will need to cross will be New Year’s Eve.  Then I will set my sights on Valentine’s Day… after that – Black Party, the arrival of spring, Pride, my birthday in July… and, eventually, I’ll be dieting and over training for Halloween again.  And the day after each big event I will eat a chocolate cake.  Maybe a pie or some ice cream.  I will do this because that is my pattern.

 It doesn’t have to be.

Crash diets have been a part of our culture for decades.  Everyone knows what they are and everyone has tried it, at least once.  People want to lose a few pounds so they will look great for a specific occasion… maybe a reunion or a photo shoot, possibly a big birthday or an award ceremony.  So they restrict, extremely, their caloric intake to lose both weight and inches.  There are several famous crash diets like the Cabbage Soup Diet, the Master Cleanse, The Grapefruit Diet that many have tried and seen results in their quest; temporary results and results that are actually damaging in the long run.  These diets focus on removing the calories but what they also do is remove the nutrients, which can lead to long term damage to organs like the brain, kidney, heart (things that you will want to hang onto, for future use), bones and your metabolism.  The lack of nutrients affects your immune system and you get sick easier and there are emotional and psychological side effects.

I think it’s just a lot easier to eat healthy foods and to exercise.

Dr Jason Piken of Innate Chiropractic believes in detox cleanses used as a launch pad for a lifestyle change, as long as it is a cleanse that fills the body with nutrients; he is quick to point out that it is, though, about making a lifestyle change, rather than the quick removal of weight that always comes back after a fad diet.  Matthew Jenkins of New York Fitness ( ) recommends this jumping off diet:  The I’m Not Gonna Put Any Crap In My Body For Ten Days Diet.  The idea is simple: there are so many great tasting healthy foods that, if people just try to live without processed foods for ten days, they will begin to notice that they actually feel better, as well as how good real food tastes.  It’s a good place to start, but it’s only a start.  The combination of eating healthy, balanced, properly proportioned meals throughout the day has to be combined with physical activity.  That’s right… Exercise.  There are so many different kinds of exercise, though, that it should not be difficult to find one that you like.  From walking to weightlifting, from Prancercise to kickboxing – there is a physical activity that habitual crash dieters can add to a new food plan to change their lives for the better.  That’s what it’s about, isn’t it?  Changing your life into something better?

Here’s the thing, though: a change that you make in your life, in the food you eat, in the exercise you get, has to be about more than just how you look.  A crash diet is of the moment and it doesn’t pay off.  We are talking about living longer, living healthier, feeling better and, ultimately, being happier.  It’s a gradual thing that you do FOR YOURSELF, not to get other peoples’ admiration or approval.  It has to be a conscious choice to make the most of your life.  You have to choose yourself; and when you go on a crash diet, it is of the moment and seldom about yourself. 

So my extreme Halloween diet is off the table and replaced by something reasonable.  Today, I choose me.


Here is the story as it was printed:












Top! Copyright © Stephen Mosher